Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Laura Gibbs's avatar

I've been so busy I haven't had time to write in response to the prompts over the past few days but I love reading your emails, and this is the card that really stuck with me and made me think exactly because the emperor seems so antithetical to my values, practices, etc. But then I started thinking about language and language rules, and there really are language rules, and I really do obey them and so does everybody else: that's how language works. (And I don't mean superficial stylistic writing conventions, etc.; I mean the deep structural rules about morphology and syntax that are how languages exist)... so at the same time that I'm obeying all those languages rules as I write this, I'm also aware that language is changing; language is changing all the time... but it's like that king on the chessboard (that's the comparison that really got me thinking), only being able to move one square at a time just because he is so rule-bound. Anyway, that's not directly relevant to the questions you ask here about the "emperor" as he figures in our educational contexts (and I'm glad that, being retired now, I am not fighting those imperial forces at my school anymore) -- but my work these days is mostly teaching languages and thinking about language, the Emperor here surprisingly gave me things to think about, so I wanted to make sure I left a comment on this post at least! And thank you for ALL the posts.

Expand full comment

No posts